World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Big Tech’s compliance with EU market rules is performative, consumer group says
The European Consumer Organisation (BEUC) says major technology companies’ efforts to comply with the EU’s Digital Markets Act have not given consumers meaningful choice. It is urging the European Commission to take a tougher approach, arguing that barriers to switching services and controlling personal data undermine the law’s aim of making digital markets fairer and more competitive.
BEUC’s analysis covers potential breaches reported to the Commission between June 2025 and June 2026, involving Alphabet, Amazon, Apple, ByteDance, Meta and Microsoft. It cites claims that Microsoft and Google use consent prompts and default settings that favour their own services, alongside concerns about Apple’s limits on alternative app distribution and Amazon’s data consent design. Google was fined €890 million in July over its Search and Play Store practices; Microsoft and Amazon said they are engaging with the Commission or offer informed choice, while Apple has introduced new developer terms that BEUC says may not resolve fundamental concerns.
In short
- BEUC says DMA compliance has not delivered meaningful consumer choice.
- It cites alleged barriers to switching services and managing personal data.
- Google was fined €890 million over Search and Play Store practices.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
BEUC’s case is that formal compliance is not enough if defaults, consent prompts or restrictions still make it difficult for people to switch services, control their data or use alternatives. A tougher Commission response could make the Digital Markets Act meaningful in practice and help consumers benefit from more competition and choice.
The case against
Technology companies can argue that compliance involves complex services and that consent prompts, default settings and app distribution rules must also balance usability, security and privacy. They may contend that engagement with the Commission and changes to their services show the rules are being implemented, and that regulators should assess specific practices carefully rather than assume they are merely performative.