Video games news, releases, esports and culture — all the biggest gaming stories in one place.
‘Now, more than ever, it’s about design’: John Romero loves that games are easier to make but warns ‘most are trash’
John Romero says games are easier to make and publish than at any point in his career, opening the door for more people to create and share their work. But he argues that this has also made it harder for good games to stand out, so strong design matters more than ever.
Romero recalled that distribution and finding a publisher were difficult when he began, and that Doom’s success came through both mail-order and retail sales. Today, developers have access to engines, frameworks and digital marketplaces, but Romero says many releases, particularly on mobile, are low quality or automatically generated. He advises indie developers to show their games at festivals and build networks, saying word of mouth follows when a game is good.
In short
- Digital publishing has made game creation more accessible.
- Romero says mobile stores are especially crowded with low-quality games.
- Strong design and word of mouth can help indie games stand out.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Accessible tools and digital marketplaces have lowered the barriers to making and publishing games, giving more people a chance to create, find an audience and build careers without first securing a publisher. The greater volume of releases can also make design and festival showcases more important ways for distinctive games to earn attention.
The case against
Lower barriers can flood marketplaces with low-quality or automatically generated releases, making it harder for players to find worthwhile games and for thoughtful independent work to be noticed. From this perspective, easier production and distribution are valuable only if developers also invest in quality and discoverability, and the sheer volume of releases can make that harder.
Explained simply
John Romero is a video game designer best known for helping create Doom, a landmark 1990s computer game. In his early career, making a game was only part of the challenge: developers also needed a publisher and ways to get copies into players’ hands, such as mail-order and shops.
Today, software tools and online shops make it easier for individuals and small teams to build and release games. That means players have many more games to choose from, while developers compete for attention. Romero’s comments centre on how thoughtful design can help a game stand out, and how festivals and personal recommendations can help people discover it.