World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Majority of people who have been in US prisons were also victims of violent crime, study finds
A survey-based study has found that most people who have been in US prisons or jails experienced violent crime before their first incarceration. Its authors say the findings point to a need for trauma recovery and support alongside responses focused on punishment, as unaddressed harm can contribute to substance use and further violence.
The nationally representative survey covered 20,000 Americans; 84% of previously incarcerated respondents said they had been assaulted, shot or stabbed before their first time in custody. Half reported being hurt by a caregiver as a child, and one-third had experienced sexual or intimate partner violence. The report also describes former prisoner Jemaine Hunter, who served 23 years and now supports young people, and recommends steps to help victims avoid involvement in crime.
In short
- 84% of formerly incarcerated respondents reported prior violent victimisation.
- Many also experienced childhood abuse or sexual and partner violence.
- Researchers call for better trauma recovery and support.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The findings support addressing trauma and victimisation as part of criminal justice policy: many people enter custody after serious harm, and untreated trauma may contribute to substance use or further violence. Pairing accountability with recovery services and early support could help victims avoid becoming involved in crime and reduce further harm.
The case against
A history of victimisation does not remove responsibility for offences or establish that trauma caused them, so policy should avoid treating support as a substitute for proportionate accountability. The survey describes respondents’ experiences but, on its own, does not show which interventions prevent reoffending; resources should be directed towards approaches shown to improve safety and outcomes.
Americas Politics Research Science World