World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Publishers ‘send out pornographic images of Gisele Pelicot taken by her rapist husband’ without her consent to promote book that criticises her
Publisher Tinbad is reported to have sent pornographic images of Gisèle Pelicot to news outlets without her consent to promote a forthcoming book about her case. The book reportedly challenges her account of being raped while drugged, making the images’ alleged use especially contentious and prompting her lawyers to consider legal action.
The book, by psychoanalyst Sabine Prokhoris, is due out on 26 November and reportedly describes Pelicot as having consented and characterises her decision to hold the trial publicly as exhibitionistic. These claims conflict with her testimony that the images were taken without her knowledge. Her former husband, Dominique Pelicot, was sentenced to 20 years in prison in December 2024; a further 50 men were convicted of sexual offences after the trial in Avignon.
In short
- Publisher reportedly shared Pelicot images without her consent.
- The book reportedly disputes her account of the abuse.
- Her lawyers are considering possible legal action.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
A publisher may argue that sharing material relevant to a forthcoming book is part of legitimate public debate about a high-profile trial, and that a challenging interpretation of the evidence deserves scrutiny rather than suppression. It could also contend that any legal questions about the images should be assessed through established privacy, copyright and consent law, while distinguishing the book’s arguments from the publisher’s promotional choices.
The case against
Pelicot’s advocates would argue that distributing intimate images allegedly made without her knowledge or consent compounds the original violation, particularly when used to promote a book disputing her account. They would say that public interest in examining a trial does not justify exposing a survivor to renewed harm or treating the images as promotional material, and that her choice to hold proceedings publicly does not amount to consent to their wider circulation.
Explained simply
Gisèle Pelicot’s case centres on crimes committed by her former husband, Dominique Pelicot, who drugged her and arranged for other men to assault her. At the trial in Avignon, he and 50 other men were convicted of sexual offences; he was sentenced to 20 years in prison in December 2024.
Pelicot has said she was unaware of the assaults and of images made while she was drugged. She chose to have the trial held in public, bringing unusual attention to questions of consent, privacy and how sexual violence is discussed.
The forthcoming book by psychoanalyst Sabine Prokhoris disputes Pelicot’s account and her reasons for choosing a public trial. The reported use of the images to promote it has raised questions about consent and the rights of people depicted in intimate images.