World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Child killer Susan Smith was in a ‘love triangle’ with her own mom and stepfather, reveals forensic psychiatrist
A South Carolina parole board denied Susan Smith parole for a second time, after a forensic psychiatrist described how abuse and turmoil in Smith’s childhood shaped her relationships. Smith is serving a life sentence for drowning her two young sons in 1994.
Dr Jessie Hill said Smith’s mother sometimes accused her of pursuing her stepfather, whom Hill said sexually abused Smith from early adolescence. Hill reported that Smith had struggled with impulsivity and judgment in prison but showed improvement from about 2015, which she linked to age, medication, family deaths and changes in religious faith. Smith apologised at the hearing and said she wanted to help others if released; the boys’ father urged the board to keep her imprisoned. Her previous parole request was denied in 2024.
In short
- Susan Smith was denied parole for a second time.
- A psychiatrist described abuse and conflict in her childhood.
- The father of Smith’s sons urged the board to deny release.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
A case for parole could emphasise Smith’s reported improvement over many years, her treatment and greater maturity, alongside her apology and stated wish to help others. Parole would allow the board to recognise rehabilitation while imposing strict conditions and continuing to assess public safety; it would not erase the grave harm she caused.
The case against
A case against parole could stress that Smith deliberately killed her two young children, an irreversible crime whose severity warrants continued imprisonment. The board may also judge that reported progress and remorse do not sufficiently establish that release would protect the public or meet the enduring needs of the victims’ family.
Explained simply
Susan Smith is serving a life sentence for the 1994 deaths of her sons, Michael and Alexander, who were three and 14 months old. She initially claimed they had been taken in a carjacking, then admitted she had driven the car into a lake with the boys inside.
Smith’s childhood and later relationships have been discussed in court and parole proceedings. A forensic psychiatrist told the board that Smith’s mother accused her of pursuing her stepfather, and that the stepfather sexually abused Smith from early adolescence.
In South Carolina, people serving life sentences may apply for parole, but release is not automatic. The board considers factors including the offence, conduct in prison and views from those affected; the boys’ father has opposed Smith’s release.