Science news and discussion on TalkFuse.
At COP31, conflict over climate science slows action on global warming
Disagreement at COP31 over when to publish the IPCC’s next major climate assessment is threatening to slow international climate action. The report is intended to inform a 2028 review of countries’ progress, and observers warn that relying on older science could weaken the basis for decisions on emissions and climate impacts.
The EU, Brazil, the UK and climate-vulnerable island states support publication in 2028, while Russia, Iran, India and Saudi Arabia want it delayed until 2029. Those countries cite concerns about the short timetable and participation by developing nations; funding disputes have also stalled planning. More than 100 researchers from 36 countries say the 2028 schedule is achievable, but uncertainty could delay the report and its influence on negotiations.
In short
- COP31 countries are split over the timing of the next IPCC report.
- The report could guide the 2028 global climate stocktake.
- Funding and scheduling disputes risk delaying climate action.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Publishing the assessment in 2028 would give countries the latest available evidence for the planned review of their climate commitments, helping ensure decisions reflect current risks and emissions trends. Supporters argue that more than 100 researchers consider the timetable achievable, and that delay could leave climate-vulnerable countries relying on outdated findings when pressing for stronger action.
The case against
A 2029 publication could allow more time for researchers, including those from developing countries, to participate meaningfully and for the assessment to be prepared carefully. Those favouring delay can argue that a report seen as rushed or insufficiently inclusive may have less credibility and legitimacy, ultimately weakening its value in international negotiations.
Explained simply
The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) is a United Nations body that reviews research on climate change and its effects. Its assessments give governments a shared evidence base for discussing emissions, climate risks and possible responses.
Countries meet at UN climate conferences to negotiate how to address global warming. They have agreed to take stock of progress in 2028, and the timing of the next IPCC assessment matters because it could provide updated evidence for that review.
The European Union, Brazil, the UK and small island states support a 2028 assessment, while Russia, Iran, India and Saudi Arabia favour 2029. The debate also involves how to give researchers in developing countries time and resources to take part.
Climate Geopolitics Politics Science World