World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Shenzhen was not Yalta, but Europe was definitively sidelined
Donald Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin held the first summit between US, Chinese and Russian leaders, meeting for about 90 minutes on the sidelines of the Apec summit in Shenzhen. The article argues that the gathering’s format, with no European leaders present, may matter more than its limited declaration: it signals Europe’s exclusion from a forum of major powers, though it produced no agreement to divide up the world.
The four-point declaration called for UN reform, greater supplies of refined petroleum products, respect for state consent and officials’ immunities, and dialogue on reducing nuclear risks. The energy pledge was its only potentially concrete measure; it set no limits on the three countries’ nuclear arsenals. The statement did not address the wars in Ukraine or Iran, Gaza, Taiwan, North Korea or artificial intelligence, and criticised the jurisdiction of the International Criminal Court and similar bodies.
In short
- Trump, Xi and Putin met without European leaders.
- Their declaration offered few concrete commitments.
- The summit left major conflicts and flashpoints unaddressed.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The summit’s format itself could signal a shift in influence: three major powers met without European leaders, despite Europe’s direct interests in issues such as Ukraine and international security. If decisions and norms are increasingly shaped in forums that exclude Europe, its ability to protect its interests and uphold multilateral rules may weaken, even without a formal agreement to divide the world.
The case against
A single meeting does not establish that Europe has been permanently sidelined or that the three leaders have formed a durable bloc. The declaration was narrow and largely aspirational, with no settlement of major conflicts or limits on nuclear arsenals; Europe also remains influential through its own institutions and alliances, so the summit’s practical consequences may be modest.
Americas Asia Europe Government Politics World