Politics news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Burnham rejects calls for devolution of powers in letter to Welsh FM
Prime Minister Andy Burnham has rejected calls to transfer policing, justice, Crown Estate and rail infrastructure powers from Westminster to Wales. His decision challenges the Welsh government’s long-standing case for greater devolution and drew criticism from First Minister Rhun ap Iorwerth, who said it showed Wales was not being treated as an equal nation.
In a letter, Burnham argued that shared policing and justice systems support cross-border work and give Wales access to national resources and expertise. He said the Crown Estate’s current model best serves Wales and that Great British Railways should work with Welsh bodies to deliver infrastructure, warning that full devolution could fragment the rail network. Welsh Labour leader Ken Skates has also backed devolving policing and the Crown Estate.
In short
- Burnham rejects calls to devolve four areas of power to Wales.
- He says shared systems support policing, justice and rail services.
- Rhun ap Iorwerth says the decision turns its back on devolution.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Keeping policing, justice, the Crown Estate and rail planning at a UK level could preserve shared systems, support cross-border cooperation and give Wales access to national expertise and resources. On this view, coordinated rail decisions can also reduce fragmentation, while devolving functions without clear arrangements might make delivery less consistent.
The case against
Transferring these powers could let Wales shape institutions and investment around its own needs and make decisions more directly accountable to Welsh voters. Supporters may argue that cooperation between nations can continue through agreements, and that retaining control at Westminster risks leaving Wales with less influence over matters that significantly affect it.