World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Supplying nuclear subs to Australia could deplete fleet for ‘many years,’ CBO warns
The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) warned that selling Virginia-class submarines to Australia under the AUKUS agreement could leave the US submarine fleet depleted for many years. The warning highlights a potential trade-off between helping Australia build its submarine capability and maintaining the size of the US fleet.
The CBO included its assessment in a broader analysis of US Navy shipbuilding and projected fleet size over the next 30 years. AUKUS, signed in 2021 by the United States, the United Kingdom and Australia, aims to help Australia develop its own submarine industry; as an interim measure, the US is expected to sell Australia between three and five Virginia-class nuclear submarines.
In short
- CBO warns AUKUS submarine sales could reduce the US fleet for years.
- The US plans to sell Australia three to five Virginia-class submarines.
- The agreement also aims to help Australia build its submarine industry.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Supplying Virginia-class submarines could strengthen Australia’s ability to help deter threats in the Indo-Pacific and deepen long-term defence cooperation among the AUKUS partners. Supporters may judge that closer allied capacity is worth some temporary pressure on the US fleet, particularly if the arrangement improves shared security and Australia develops a lasting submarine capability.
The case against
The US submarine fleet is itself a vital part of national defence, and transferring boats while shipbuilding struggles to keep pace could leave fewer submarines available for US missions for many years. Critics may argue that the United States should first ensure its own fleet can meet its commitments, since the security benefits of helping Australia would not offset a prolonged shortfall in US capacity.
Explained simply
AUKUS is a security agreement signed in 2021 by Australia, the United Kingdom and the United States. It includes plans to help Australia develop the ability to build and operate nuclear-powered submarines.
Australia is expected to receive three to five Virginia-class submarines from the US as an interim step. These submarines are built for the US Navy, which also needs to maintain its own fleet.
The issue matters because submarine production takes years, so supplying boats to Australia could affect how many are available to the US Navy over time. The Congressional Budget Office examines these pressures as part of its analysis of Navy shipbuilding and the future fleet.