World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Cardinals finally give up on former top prospect Nolan Gorman
The St Louis Cardinals will not offer Nolan Gorman a new contract, making the 26-year-old infielder a free agent once the move is official. The decision ends his run with the club after his promising 2023 season, when he hit 27 home runs, and reflects a sharp decline in his production since then.
Gorman hit 42 home runs with a .645 OPS over the three seasons after his breakout, and struck out in 33.8 per cent of his 1,883 career plate appearances. He spent much of 2026 with Triple-A Memphis, batting .182, while rookie JJ Wetherholt took over at second base. A projected $3.4 million salary for 2027 reportedly made Gorman difficult to trade; the Cardinals plan to tender their other players ahead of Friday’s 5 p.m. ET deadline.
In short
- St Louis will not tender Nolan Gorman a contract.
- Gorman is set to become a free agent.
- A .182 Triple-A average marked his 2026 season.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The Cardinals can reasonably conclude that Gorman’s declining production, high strikeout rate and poor Triple-A season make a new contract an unjustified use of limited roster and salary resources. With Wetherholt established at second base and Gorman difficult to trade at his projected salary, letting him go gives the club room to pursue players better suited to its plans.
The case against
The Cardinals could reasonably argue that Gorman’s 27-home-run 2023 season shows there is still upside worth exploring, and that his subsequent struggles may not erase the value of a young player with major-league power. A modest contract or a different role might have given him a chance to recover while preserving an asset the club could otherwise lose for nothing.