World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Doctor restricted from treating children gave evidence in parents’ prosecution
Professor Peter Hindmarsh, whose evidence helped secure Lucy Letby’s convictions, wrote a key prosecution report in a separate case after his hospital employer had barred him from treating child patients with diabetes. The disclosure raises questions about whether those concerns should have been shared with investigators and the parents’ defence, and may affect the appeal by Damion and Tamara Thomas, who say they were unaware of the restriction.
The Thomases were prosecuted after their 12-year-old son Joshua died in December 2022 following his first diabetes episode. Hindmarsh’s August 2023 report said his symptoms should have prompted earlier medical help; Tamara was convicted of gross negligence manslaughter and neglect, while Damion was convicted of neglect. UCLH had informed the General Medical Council in March 2023 that it considered Hindmarsh a risk to children, but the CPS reportedly learnt of the GMC investigation and concerns only after he disclosed details in December 2025.
In short
- Hindmarsh wrote a prosecution report after being barred from treating child patients.
- The report helped convict Tamara and Damion Thomas of offences involving their son.
- The family says they did not know about the restriction and is seeking to appeal.
Read the full article at the source →
Originally published by The Guardian as “Letby trial doctor barred from treating patients was expert witness in another case”.