Science news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Why Is the World Still Counting on Unproven Carbon Capture Technology?
Climate models and climate pledges rely heavily on carbon capture and storage (CCS), which is meant to trap carbon dioxide and store it underground. But reporting found little evidence that the technology can be deployed at the scale assumed, raising concerns about climate plans that depend on it instead of cutting emissions.
After three decades of development, only 12 large-scale geological storage projects have been built, and at least seven underperformed or failed. The article says the world stored less carbon dioxide underground last year than a single large power plant emits annually, while some models assume capture rates as high as 92%. One model leader said those rates reflect expected carbon taxes and subsidies; the provided article text ends before explaining further findings.
In short
- Climate plans assume CCS will work at vast scale.
- Only 12 large storage projects have been built.
- Some models assume capture rates of up to 92%.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
CCS could help address emissions that are difficult to eliminate, while allowing industries and energy systems time to transition. Its limited record may reflect weak incentives and early-stage deployment; carbon pricing, subsidies and continued investment could improve performance and make it a useful part of climate plans.
The case against
Climate plans that count on large future volumes of captured carbon risk delaying direct emissions cuts, even though the technology has so far delivered little storage and several projects have underperformed or failed. Given that gap between current results and model assumptions, relying on CCS at scale could leave climate targets unmet if deployment does not improve quickly.
Explained simply
Carbon capture and storage is designed to stop carbon dioxide from reaching the atmosphere by trapping it and storing it underground. Governments and energy companies have developed projects over several decades, but large-scale geological storage remains limited.
Climate researchers use models to explore ways to meet targets for limiting global warming. Some models include substantial future use of carbon capture, while governments and companies may also include it in climate plans; assumptions about its growth depend partly on expected policies such as carbon taxes and subsidies.
The issue matters because plans that count on storing large amounts of carbon dioxide may be harder to achieve if the technology does not expand as expected. How much it can contribute is relevant alongside efforts to reduce emissions at their source.