Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
10 Most Thrilling Documentaries of All Time
Collider has published a ranked list of the ten most thrilling documentaries ever made, arguing that while documentaries need not always aim to entertain in the manner of a feature film, certain subjects lend themselves to a fast-paced, engrossing approach. Writer Jeremy Urquhart contends that, in the right hands, even weighty material can be made compelling without seeming disrespectful, and that the films selected stand out for being unpredictable and consistently interesting to watch.
The entries tend to cover the sorts of subjects usually found in drama and thriller films, with several blurring the line between documentary and feature filmmaking. At number ten is Touching the Void (2003), a mountaineering survival story about Joe Simpson and Simon Yates nearly dying in the Peruvian Andes after climbing Siula Grande, which uses dramatisations to function almost as a drama. At number nine is Shirkers (2018), a Netflix film about an unfinished independent thriller shot in the early 1990s whose footage disappeared with the man holding it, only to resurface years later along with the story behind its loss and recovery.
In short
- Collider ranks the ten most thrilling documentaries ever made.
- Touching the Void (2003) takes tenth, a mountaineering survival tale.
- Shirkers (2018) ranks ninth, about lost then recovered film footage.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Well-crafted documentaries can engage audiences emotionally whilst maintaining integrity and respect for their subjects. When skilled filmmakers apply cinematic techniques to compelling true stories, they create accessible, memorable work that prompts genuine consideration without compromising factual accuracy. Entertainment and documentary value need not conflict; indeed, making weighty subjects engaging ensures broader audiences encounter and genuinely consider important material.
The case against
Prioritising thrilling entertainment risks subordinating truth and nuance to narrative drama and sensationalism. When filmmakers focus on what entertains rather than what matters most, they may simplify complex subjects, exploit suffering for effect, or blur fact and fiction in ways audiences don't fully appreciate. Documentary's primary obligation is truthful documentation and rigorous education, not competition with fiction films for entertainment value.
Explained simply
A documentary is a film that presents real events and real people, using actual footage and interviews rather than actors and scripts. Whilst documentaries often explore serious or educational topics, some filmmakers have discovered that true stories can be told with the pace and suspense of a thriller, making them both intellectually engaging and entertaining to watch.
The most gripping documentaries tend to cover subjects that naturally contain dramatic elements, such as survival stories, mysteries, or unexpected revelations. These films sometimes blur the line between pure documentary and dramatised storytelling, using reconstructed scenes or interviews to recreate events that could not be filmed at the time, whilst remaining rooted in actual events.
Such films demonstrate that documentaries and dramas need not be in opposition to one another. The most effective thrilling documentaries treat their real subjects with respect whilst refusing to sacrifice pace or audience engagement, proving that non-fiction can captivate viewers as powerfully as any work of fiction.