New releases, music videos and album news — indie, rap, rock and pop. Always covering Ren, Chris Webby, Sam Tompkins, bbno$, CHINCHILLA, Muse, Yungblud and more.
Annie Leibovitz Sues Observer Over Justin and Hailey Bieber Photo: ‘Exploitation’
Annie Leibovitz has taken legal action against Observer Media, which operates Observer.com, over the unauthorized use of one of her photographs. The disputed image, captured in 2019, shows newlyweds Justin and Hailey Bieber in coordinated Dolce & Gabbana outfits and was published alongside a 2020 article on the website without the photographer's consent.
When Leibovitz's licensing agency notified Observer Media in May 2024 that the image infringed on her copyright and demanded its removal, the company did not comply. The photograph remained live on the site months later, prompting Leibovitz to file suit in Manhattan federal court, where she claims the infringement was deliberate and malicious, seeking damages of up to $150,000.
In short
- Photographer Annie Leibovitz filed suit against Observer Media for publishing her 2019 photo of Justin and Hailey Bieber without license or permission
- After Leibovitz's licensing agency sent a takedown notice in May 2024 that was ignored, she is seeking damages up to $150,000 for alleged willful copyright infringement
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Professional photographers' livelihoods depend on strict copyright protection and licensing fees that publishers must respect. Annie Leibovitz's ownership of this image is a fundamental intellectual property right that must be enforced. Observer Media's deliberate decision to ignore the May 2024 takedown notice demonstrates willful bad-faith infringement that warrants substantial damages to create meaningful deterrence.
The case against
Whilst copyright deserves genuine protection, the $150,000 damages sought appear punitive rather than proportionate to actual harm caused. Digital publishers often encounter legitimate licensing complexities when managing complex platforms, and the core remedy—prompt removal of infringing content—addresses the substantive wrong. Excessive financial penalties chill legitimate journalism and create disproportionate consequences, and a more balanced approach would prioritise actual damages compensation over punitive measures designed to send a message.
Explained simply
Annie Leibovitz is one of the world's most celebrated photographers, known for intimate celebrity and fashion portraits published in major magazines and displayed in galleries and museums globally. Her photographs are typically licensed, meaning publications must pay to use them.
A 2019 photograph she took of newlyweds Justin Bieber and Hailey Bieber appeared on the website Observer.com in a 2020 article without her permission or knowledge. When her representatives discovered the unauthorised use and demanded removal in May 2024, the website did not comply.
Copyright and licensing disputes between photographers and media organisations remain common in the industry. Photographers maintain strict control over their work and compensation for its use, whilst news and entertainment sites need imagery to illustrate stories. This case reflects ongoing tensions between these interests in modern publishing.