The Odyssey features an ensemble cast, but actor Himesh Patel has generated notable fan appreciation for his portrayal of Eurylochus, a crew member on Odysseus's voyage. Despite not being prominently highlighted in the film's promotional campaign, audiences have actively praised his contribution and called for greater recognition of his work.

Fan commentary emphasises that Patel's screen time is more significant than the marketing suggests, appearing throughout much of the film's runtime. Viewers specifically commend his performance for authenticity and note his character's role in questioning Odysseus's decisions, with many suggesting his work deserves higher profile acknowledgment.