World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
40 Years Later, Hollywood Still Hasn’t Learned the Right Lesson from ‘Highlander’
Polygon argues that the 1986 film Highlander was poorly received for good reason, despite later becoming a VHS cult favourite and launching a wider franchise. The article says Hollywood risks drawing the wrong lesson from its enduring fanbase as a Henry Cavill-led reboot approaches, potentially repeating the original’s overly sombre tone rather than embracing the premise’s inherent absurdity.
The original made $12.8 million against a $19 million budget and was heavily criticised on release, though its sword fights, Scottish scenery and fantasy concept are acknowledged as strengths. Its plot follows immortal Scottish warrior Connor MacLeod, who ultimately fights rival immortals in 1980s New York; the writer contends that Sean Connery’s lighter, more playful performance offered the kind of campy energy the film otherwise lacked. Early images from the reboot appear similarly gloomy, prompting concern that it will retain the same self-serious approach.
In short
- Polygon says Highlander’s cult status does not make it a misunderstood classic.
- The original’s premise needed more humour and self-awareness.
- The Cavill reboot may repeat its overly serious tone.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The reboot could reasonably treat Highlander’s lasting appeal as evidence that its mythology, sword fights and distinctive settings have enduring power, while aiming for a sombre tone that gives the immortals’ long lives and conflicts emotional weight. Early images may not capture the finished film, and a serious approach could offer a coherent interpretation rather than simply repeating the original’s choices.
The case against
The original’s poor reception suggests that its strong premise and striking elements were not enough to make its overly sombre tone work, while its later cult following does not prove that this tone was what audiences loved. A reboot that leans into the story’s inherent absurdity and the playful energy of Sean Connery’s performance could better distinguish itself and make the material more entertaining.
Explained simply
Highlander is a fantasy film first released in 1986. It follows Connor MacLeod, a Scottish warrior who cannot die and is drawn into a long-running fight among immortal warriors, ending in 1980s New York.
The film performed poorly in cinemas and received a mixed response from critics, but later found a large audience on VHS and grew into a franchise. Its sword fights, Scottish scenery and unusual premise helped it endure, while Sean Connery’s more playful performance brought a lighter note to its sombre tone.
A reboot starring Henry Cavill is in development. The debate around it reflects a broader question for Hollywood: whether to recreate the original’s serious style or make more room for the premise’s fantastical and playful elements.