Politics news and discussion on TalkFuse.
A Democratic scheme to expand the welfare state unlawfully
The article argues that the Biden administration unlawfully expanded food-stamp benefits in 2021, bypassing Congress. Its author says the episode shows how Democrats may use cooperation with outside groups to pursue welfare-policy changes without legislative approval.
The increase used the US Department of Agriculture’s Thrifty Food Plan formula and raised benefits by 27% on average. The article estimates it will cost taxpayers nearly $230 billion over ten years and describes it as the largest permanent increase in food-stamp spending in US history.
In short
- Biden raised food-stamp benefits by 27% on average in 2021.
- The increase is estimated to cost nearly $230 billion over ten years.
- The article argues Congress did not approve the change.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Supporters could argue that updating the Thrifty Food Plan was a lawful exercise of authority Congress had delegated to the Agriculture Department, and that the previous formula no longer reflected the cost of a nutritious diet. A substantial increase could help low-income households afford food and reduce hardship, with its cost justified as a public investment in basic security.
The case against
Critics could argue that a permanent 27% average increase, with a large long-term cost, amounted to a major policy change that should have been authorised by Congress rather than made through administrative action. They may also contend that relying on outside groups in shaping the formula risks weakening accountability and public confidence in how federal benefits are set.
Explained simply
The US food-stamp programme, now called SNAP, helps people on low incomes pay for groceries. Congress sets the programme’s rules, while the Department of Agriculture works out benefit levels using a formula called the Thrifty Food Plan, which estimates the cost of a basic healthy diet.
In 2021, the Biden administration revised that formula, increasing benefits by an average of 27%. The change has prompted disagreement over how much discretion the department had under the law and whether Congress should have approved the increase.
The debate matters because SNAP reaches millions of households and is funded by federal taxpayers. It also raises broader questions about how far an administration can change a major public programme using existing legal powers.