Technology news and discussion on TalkFuse.
NSW probes claims Aboriginal family were removed from bus over crying toddler
Transport for NSW is investigating allegations that a Wiradjuri mother, her 22-month-old daughter and her mother were ordered off a regional bus because the toddler was crying. The family were left beside a highway, and the incident has prompted questions about passenger safety, the treatment of Aboriginal families and the operator’s policies.
Kaneesha Lee Williams said the driver stopped about 15 minutes after the bus left Wagga Wagga and gave no warning before telling them to get off. A teenage passenger said the family left the bus and it departed after about five minutes. They had little food, no water and low phone battery, and relatives drove more than two hours to collect them. Regional Transport Minister Jenny Aitchison called the alleged conduct unacceptable; the driver is no longer employed by the operator.
In short
- NSW is investigating a family’s removal from a regional bus.
- The mother says her toddler was crying when the driver stopped.
- The driver is no longer employed by the operator.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
If the account is accurate, removing a family with a very young child over crying may have been disproportionate and left them exposed to serious safety risks beside a highway. The lack of warning and the reported shortage of food, water and phone battery strengthen calls for clear rules, staff training and safeguards against discriminatory treatment of Aboriginal passengers.
The case against
A bus operator also has a duty to protect other passengers and staff, and may need to act when conduct is causing substantial disruption or a safety concern. The full circumstances and the driver’s reasons have not yet been established, so a fair investigation should distinguish a justified response to events on board from an excessive or discriminatory decision to leave the family in an unsafe place.
Explained simply
Regional buses connect towns and cities across New South Wales, where journeys can cover long distances and passengers may have few nearby alternatives. Wagga Wagga is in the Riverina region, and Wiradjuri people are the First Nations people of much of central New South Wales.
The account concerns Kaneesha Lee Williams, her young daughter and her mother, and the bus operator responsible for their journey. Transport for NSW oversees the state’s transport services, while the regional transport minister is responsible for the government’s transport portfolio.
The claims have drawn attention to how operators manage disruption involving young children, and to the safety of passengers left far from towns or services. They have also raised questions about whether Aboriginal families are treated fairly in public transport.
Read the full article at the source →
Originally published by The Guardian as “Aboriginal mother allegedly kicked off a bus in regional NSW because her baby was crying”.