Science news and discussion on TalkFuse.
COP31 draft deal omits fossil fuels as talks run overtime
Developing story first seen 10 hours ago
No new article text has been provided beyond the earlier account, so there is no reported change to lead with. COP31 talks in Antalya ran into overtime as countries struggled to agree on a final climate deal, and the latest draft omitted any mention of fossil fuels, prompting criticism from activists and some leaders.
The voluntary agreement requires near-unanimous support from nearly 200 countries, and a third draft was expected after overnight negotiations. Disputes also covered carbon capture, climate finance for poorer countries and Europe’s carbon-related trade measures; a proposal to raise electricity’s share of global energy use from about 21% to 35% by 2035 did not specify that the power must come from renewables.
- Sources
- 5
- Outlets
- 5
- Left · Centre · Right
- 2 · 3 · 0
In short
- COP31 talks ran overtime without agreement on key issues.
- The latest draft did not mention fossil fuels.
- A third draft was expected after overnight negotiations.
How this story developed
- 3 hours ago By Friday, negotiators had postponed some decisions until next year, while organisers still hoped to reach agreement and a third draft was expected on Saturday after overnight talks.
- 9 hours ago The latest draft’s omission of fossil fuels drew protests and criticism, as delegates remained divided over a proposal to increase electricity’s share of global energy use without requiring renewable power.
- 9 hours ago COP31 negotiations in Antalya overran as nearly 200 countries struggled to agree a voluntary climate deal, with fossil fuels, funding and trade measures among the disputed issues.
- Al Jazeera Fossil fuel talks deadlock pushes COP31 climate summit into overtime
- Le Monde COP31: Fossil fuels and climate funding take center stage in final stretch of negotiations
- France 24 COP31 wrapping up in Turkey: Climate deal elusive as fossil fuels go unmentioned
- PBS NewsHour COP31 draft deal omits fossil fuels as talks run overtime
- BBC Science Fight over fossil fuels leaves COP31 climate talks in deadlock
Full account
COP31 negotiations in Antalya, Türkiye, ran beyond their scheduled Friday finish, with nearly 200 countries still divided over a wider political agreement. Delegates settled some technical matters, but postponed key decisions. Summit president Murat Kurum said the talks were nearing an outcome but had not reached one; a further draft was expected on Saturday after overnight discussions.
The latest draft does not mention fossil fuels, a conspicuous omission for a deal addressing climate change. An earlier version, prepared by Australia, called for a faster phase-out, while a subsequent draft removed the references after objections from Saudi Arabia and other oil and gas producers. The shift prompted criticism from activists and governments. Panama’s environment minister said his country would not accept a final document that left fossil fuels unmentioned, and the European Union warned the text could undermine the purpose of the summit. The agreements reached at these conferences are voluntary and generally require broad consensus.
The dispute extends beyond fossil fuels. The newer draft also omits a proposed $120 billion target for helping poorer countries adapt to climate impacts. Developing nations expressed frustration over shortfalls in climate finance, while other contested proposals concern carbon capture and a target for electricity to supply 35 per cent of global final energy use by 2035. The draft does not specify that this electricity should be renewable. Some countries argue carbon capture could prolong the use of fossil fuels; others have called for its inclusion.
The talks have taken place amid warnings that the Paris Agreement’s goal of limiting long-term warming to 1.5°C is likely to be exceeded. Environmental organisations criticised the summit’s level of ambition, with one campaigner describing it as the worst COP. Delegates also protested in the closing session: a banner read “failure”, and one demonstrator accused leaders of endangering the future. Kurum urged countries to reach consensus, while analyst Alden Meyer warned that the absence of a renewed commitment on fossil fuels would mark a setback from the agreement to transition away from them reached at COP28 in 2023.
Where outlets differ
From the full account, which is AI-written from the sources:
The Associated Press focuses on the overtime negotiations, protests in the closing session and the range of unresolved issues, including carbon capture, adaptation finance and the EU’s carbon-related trade measure. The second report gives more detail on how the draft changed: it says Australia’s opening version called for a faster phase-out, and that the later text also dropped a $120 billion adaptation target.
The second report names Panama’s threat to leave the talks, the EU’s response, and comments from ministers in Vanuatu and Ghana. The AP report instead foregrounds the protest banner and quotes analyst Alden Meyer on the risk of backtracking from COP28. Both accounts describe the fossil-fuel omission and divisions over finance and carbon capture.
Left-leaning outlets 2
- Fossil fuel talks deadlock pushes COP31 climate summit into overtimeAl Jazeera
- COP31: Fossil fuels and climate funding take center stage in final stretch of negotiationsLe Monde
Only here: fuel, pushes, summit, funding, take
Centre outlets 3
- COP31 draft deal omits fossil fuels as talks run overtimePBS NewsHour
- COP31 wrapping up in Turkey: Climate deal elusive as fossil fuels go unmentionedFrance 24
- Fight over fossil fuels leaves COP31 climate talks in deadlockBBC Science
Only here: deal, draft, omits, wrapping, turkey
Every side used: fossil, talks, deadlock, cop31, climate, overtime
Headline columns compared word for word; nothing in them is AI-written.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
A deal that nearly 200 countries can support may be more useful than stronger language that causes key parties to walk away. Supporters of the draft could argue that keeping negotiations open on contentious issues, including fossil fuels and climate finance, preserves room for agreement and practical cooperation.
The case against
Leaving fossil fuels out of the draft avoids addressing the main driver of climate change and risks making the agreement inadequate to the scale of the problem. Critics could argue that without clear commitments on phasing down fossil fuels and ensuring new electricity comes from renewables, a broad but vague deal may offer little progress towards limiting warming.
Explained simply
COP is the UN’s annual climate summit, where almost every country negotiates shared steps to address global warming. The Paris Agreement, reached in 2015, commits countries to limit the rise in global temperatures and calls for efforts to keep it to 1.5°C above pre-industrial levels.
Countries bring different priorities to the talks, including how quickly to move away from fossil fuels such as coal, oil and gas, and how to pay for climate measures. Poorer countries often seek funding to adapt to climate impacts, while governments also debate technologies such as carbon capture and rules affecting trade and emissions.
Any COP deal is voluntary and needs near-unanimous agreement, so the wording can shape what countries are expected to pursue while leaving room for national choices. Electricity can be generated from fossil fuels or renewable sources, making the distinction important when countries discuss expanding its role in energy use.
Coverage · 5 sources
Bias meters
From 5 rated sources.
- PBS NewsHourCentreCOP31 draft deal omits fossil fuels as talks run overtime
- Al JazeeraLeftFossil fuel talks deadlock pushes COP31 climate summit into overtime
- Le MondeLeftCOP31: Fossil fuels and climate funding take center stage in final stretch of negotiations
- France 24CentreCOP31 wrapping up in Turkey: Climate deal elusive as fossil fuels go unmentioned
- BBC ScienceCentreFight over fossil fuels leaves COP31 climate talks in deadlock
Read the full article at the source →
Originally published by PBS NewsHour as “Activists, leaders criticize COP31 climate talks as fossil fuels go unmentioned in draft deal”.