Technology news and discussion on TalkFuse.
AI Threatens the Value We Put on Creativity
Joel Goodman, an Emmy-winning composer and music publisher, argues that generative AI could make creative work economically irrelevant if companies can train commercial systems on copyrighted music without permission or payment. He says AI differs from earlier music technology because it can generate material itself, potentially redirecting attention and income away from human creators.
Goodman points to the AI-generated band The Velvet Sundown, which reached Spotify’s Viral 50 in 2025, released four albums in under two months and gained more than a million monthly listeners before being exposed as fictitious. He acknowledges that artists have always learned from earlier music, but draws a distinction between human influence and companies ingesting millions of protected works to produce derivative material. His concern is that society may mistake the ability to generate music for the creation of meaningful work.
In short
- Composer Joel Goodman warns AI could undermine the economics of creative work.
- The fictitious Velvet Sundown gained over a million monthly Spotify listeners.
- He distinguishes human musical influence from commercial training on copyrighted works.