Business news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Alan Milburn says his plan to get young people into work will save only £200m a year
Developed over time first seen 1 day ago
Alan Milburn’s proposed overhaul of support for young people outside education, work or training is expected to save the government only £200m a year overall. Most of the money raised by reducing benefits would fund new employment, education and training support, strengthening Milburn’s argument that the plan is aimed at tackling youth inactivity rather than cutting welfare spending.
The plan would spend nearly £2bn a year on a youth opportunity service, just over £2bn on vocational courses and apprenticeships, and £1bn on payments and tax breaks for employers. Changes to sickness and disability benefits for 18 to 24-year-olds are forecast to save £3.6bn by 2036-37, with higher tax receipts adding £2.4bn; together, these gains would almost match the new system’s £5.8bn cost. The report comes as the number of young people not in education, employment or training reached 1 million, or 13% of the age group.
- Sources
- 3
- Outlets
- 1
- Left · Centre · Right
- 3 · 0 · 0
In short
- Milburn’s youth employment plan would save only £200m a year overall.
- Benefit cuts and higher tax receipts would fund a new £5.8bn support system.
- The number of young people outside work or education reached 1 million.
How this story developed
- 23 hours ago Alan Milburn’s proposed overhaul of support for young people outside education, work or training is expected to save the government only £200m a year overall.
- The Guardian Burnham makes Milburn head of unit to implement new jobs and welfare approach for young people – live
- The Guardian Alan Milburn says his plan to get young people into work will save only £200m a year
- The Guardian Alan Milburn says 'Great British promise' to young people is being broken – video
Full account
Alan Milburn says his proposals to help more young people enter work would leave the government saving about £200m a year. The former health secretary’s long-awaited review recommends reducing sickness and disability benefits for under-25s and using much of the money to fund employment support. Its financial estimates show that the proposed services would absorb nearly all the expected savings from benefit changes and additional tax receipts.
The review proposes a Youth Opportunities Service offering advice and support intended to give every young person a route into education, training or work. It allocates nearly £2bn a year to that service, just over £2bn to expand vocational courses and apprenticeships, and a further £1bn to payments and tax breaks for employers who recruit young people. For 18- to 24-year-olds, personal independence payments would be replaced by a new allowance limited to people with conditions described in the report as well established, significant and ongoing. A single youth allowance would also replace existing sickness and disability support, leaving some claimants entitled to less than they can receive now.
By 2036–37, the review expects benefit changes to save £3.6bn and increased tax receipts to bring in another £2.4bn. Against those gains, it puts the cost of the new system at £5.8bn. Milburn argues that cutting support faster could expose young people to poverty, poor housing and ill health. The review was commissioned amid concern about the number of young people who are not in education, employment or training, which one report says reached one million earlier this year. The modest net saving may invite criticism from Conservatives seeking a larger reduction in welfare spending, while supporting Milburn’s case that the proposals are principally aimed at improving young people’s prospects.
The government has appointed Milburn to chair a new Youth Opportunities Unit at its centre, reporting directly to Prime Minister Andy Burnham. According to the government announcement described in the second report, the unit will coordinate the response to the review, help departments resolve obstacles, work with local leaders and employers, and use data to assess progress. The appointment signals a commitment to pursuing the proposals, although the unit’s practical influence will depend on how far ministers allow it to direct work across departments. The reports do not establish which recommendations the government has formally adopted or when any benefit changes would take effect.
Where outlets differ
From the full account, which is AI-written from the sources:
Source 1 concentrates on the review’s costs, benefit changes and political arguments. Source 2 concentrates on Milburn’s appointment to lead the new unit and considers how much authority that role may carry. Its assessment of his likely influence is commentary, rather than a confirmed power granted to the unit.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The plan could be justified as an investment in young people who are currently shut out of education and work, with tailored support, training and employer incentives aimed at improving their prospects. If it helps more people into sustainable jobs, the resulting tax receipts and reduced benefit spending could largely offset its costs while easing long-term inactivity.
The case against
Critics could argue that the projected £200m annual saving is modest beside the scale of the spending and the 1 million young people currently outside education, work or training. Reducing sickness and disability benefits for 18 to 24-year-olds also risks withdrawing support from people whose health limits their ability to work, while the expected gains depend on the new services and training translating into lasting jobs.
Explained simply
Young people not in education, employment or training are often described as NEET, meaning they are not studying, working or taking part in job training. The number in this situation has reached about one million in the UK, making it a concern for employment and education policy.
Alan Milburn is proposing changes to the support available to 18 to 24-year-olds, including help to find work, vocational courses and apprenticeships. The plan also involves changes to sickness and disability benefits and offers payments or tax breaks to employers who recruit young people.
The proposal combines spending on support with expected savings from benefit changes and increased tax receipts. Its overall cost and savings matter to the public finances, while its design is intended to address why some young people are outside work or education.
Coverage · 3 sources
Bias meters
From 3 rated sources.
- The GuardianLeftAlan Milburn says his plan to get young people into work will save only £200m a year
- The GuardianLeftBurnham makes Milburn head of unit to implement new jobs and welfare approach for young people – live
- The GuardianLeftAlan Milburn says 'Great British promise' to young people is being broken – video
Business Government Politics Software Technology UK World