Culture news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Alive by Melanie Challenger review – a maverick study of what it means to have a body
Melanie Challenger's book *Alive: The Hidden Intelligence of the Living World* argues that we have misunderstood nature and ourselves by fixating on souls, genes or minds rather than paying attention to bodies. The reviewer frames this as an important corrective, noting that bodies have been marginalised in scientific and philosophical thought, perhaps because they remind us of vulnerability and mortality, and that this neglect leads humans to disrespect other life forms and damage habitats without regard for the creatures living there.
Challenger, a poet as well as thinker, illustrates her argument with vivid descriptions of organisms ranging from slime moulds to Humboldt squid, and draws heavily on Aristotle, whom she credits as the first to intuit bodily intelligence despite lacking the science to prove it. The reviewer, framing the piece with an anecdote about their own dangerous open-water swim and resulting hypothermia, praises the book's ambition and critique of scientific reductionism but admits to feeling frequently disoriented by its dense thicket of ideas, questioning whether such a pioneering work successfully brings lay readers along with it.
In short
- Review of Melanie Challenger's book on the "intelligence" of living bodies
- Argues focus on souls/genes/minds has marginalised the body
- Reviewer praises ambition but finds the book often disorienting
Explained simply
Melanie Challenger's new book Alive argues that science and philosophy have largely overlooked the importance of bodies. Rather than focusing on souls, genes, or minds, Challenger suggests we should pay attention to how living things actually inhabit and experience the world through their physical selves.
This matters because overlooking bodies has real consequences for how we treat other creatures. When we fail to recognise that other animals experience their world through their bodies, we become indifferent to their suffering and more willing to damage the habitats they depend on to survive.
Challenger, who is both a poet and a thinker, explores her ideas through vivid descriptions of organisms ranging from simple slime moulds to complex creatures like Humboldt squid. She draws on the philosophy of Aristotle, arguing that he was the first to understand the importance of bodies, even though he lacked the modern science to back up his thinking.