World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
America Needs More Nurses. The Trump Administration Wants To Make Them Much Harder To Hire.
The Trump administration has proposed changes that would make it harder for US employers to sponsor foreign workers for permanent residence. A key proposal would remove nurses and physical therapists from Schedule A, an exemption that lets employers skip the usual labour market test for occupations recognised as facing shortages.
The wider changes would lengthen recruitment and advertising requirements and prevent employers from applying for two years after certain US worker layoffs, up from six months. The article says federal projections estimate a registered nurse shortfall of 8% in 2028 and 3% in 2038, equivalent to 108,960 full-time nurses; a physical therapy association forecasts a 3.3% shortfall by 2037. The proposal is open for public comment until 19 January.
In short
- Proposed rules could remove nurses and physical therapists from a hiring exemption.
- Federal projections estimate a 108,960 full-time nurse shortfall in 2038.
- The proposal would add recruitment requirements and lengthen the process.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Keeping nurses and physical therapists on Schedule A could help employers fill persistent shortages more quickly, especially where vacancies threaten access to care. The usual labour market test and longer recruitment rules may add delays and costs without producing enough qualified domestic applicants, while the reported projections suggest demand will continue to exceed supply.
The case against
Removing the Schedule A exemption could ensure employers demonstrate that they have made a genuine effort to recruit US workers before sponsoring someone from abroad. Longer recruitment periods and a longer pause after certain layoffs could protect domestic workers from being displaced and give them more opportunities to apply, while still allowing employers to sponsor foreign workers who meet the requirements.