World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Andy Burnham warned over slavery apology – ‘he’ll be asked for money next’
Sir John Jenkins, a former British ambassador, has criticised calls for reparations for Britain’s role in the slave trade, describing them as a “cynical and mercenary shakedown”. He argues that Andy Burnham’s openness to an apology could encourage campaigners to seek payments, and says Britain’s willingness to concede to demands risks weakening its position.
Burnham has said he is open to an apology but has opposed reparations. A 2023 study proposed that the UK pay £18.8 trillion for its involvement in slavery across 14 countries. Jenkins also criticised the Prime Minister’s support for an apology and structured dialogue, while former home secretary Suella Braverman said Britain should neither apologise nor make taxpayers pay for actions centuries ago.
In short
- Sir John Jenkins says an apology could fuel calls for reparations.
- Andy Burnham supports considering an apology but opposes payments.
- A 2023 study proposed £18.8 trillion across 14 countries.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Those opposed to an apology or reparations argue that present-day taxpayers and officials should not be held responsible for acts committed centuries ago, and that a national apology could be treated as an admission supporting demands for large payments. They also contend that accepting such demands may weaken Britain’s negotiating position and that public resources should be directed towards current needs.
The case against
Those open to an apology argue that acknowledging Britain’s role in slavery is a matter of historical honesty and respect for people affected by its lasting consequences, rather than an admission that automatically requires payment. They may see structured dialogue as a way to address historic harm and discuss possible remedies fairly, while arguing that refusing even to apologise risks dismissing those consequences and damaging trust.