Science news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Anglers fear fishing ban after ‘wildlife harmed’
Anglers in Doncaster are campaigning to prevent a potential fishing ban at Askern Lake after councillors warned that anti-social behaviour and harm to wildlife must stop. City of Doncaster Council said no ban is currently in place, but local councillors have raised concerns after birds, including geese, were injured by fishing lines and had to be taken to animal sanctuaries for care.
Councillor Gerald Squire said fishing itself was not the target but that current problems could not continue, while councillor Vicky Lawson said the trouble was mainly caused by unsupervised, bored children and some adults, with a minority harming wildlife; she suggested educating and supervising young anglers with volunteer help. Askern town councillor John Rowley, who runs a local angling supplies shop, is leading efforts to avoid a ban, arguing it would be a "knee-jerk reaction" and highlighting fishing's mental health benefits. He and around a dozen volunteers hope to set up a local fishing club issuing tickets to anglers, allowing them to monitor litter, discarded fishing lines and anti-social behaviour at the lake.
In short
- Doncaster anglers fear a ban on fishing at Askern Lake.
- Council cites wildlife injuries and anti-social behaviour, but no ban yet.
- Local campaigners plan a fishing club to self-police the site.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
A blanket ban could penalise responsible anglers for the actions of a minority and remove a valued local pastime that supporters say benefits mental health. A volunteer-run club with permits, supervision and education could address litter, unsafe fishing lines and anti-social behaviour while keeping the lake accessible.
The case against
Councillors have a duty to protect wildlife and ensure the lake is safe and pleasant for everyone, and reports of birds injured by fishing lines show that the current arrangements are causing harm. If education, supervision and volunteer monitoring cannot reliably prevent further injuries and anti-social behaviour, restricting or banning fishing may be a proportionate way to protect the lake.
Explained simply
Askern Lake is a local fishing spot in Doncaster, where anglers fish for recreation. Fishing lines have injured some birds, including geese, which have needed care at animal sanctuaries.
The council has said there is no fishing ban in place. Local councillors say wildlife harm and anti-social behaviour need to stop, while stressing that fishing itself is not the target.
Town councillor John Rowley and local volunteers want to organise a fishing club to help supervise anglers and keep the lake tidy. The debate involves how to protect wildlife and manage behaviour while preserving access to fishing.