World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
AOC, Paris Hilton, Florida Rep Lee ‘hopeful’ law against sexually explicit deepfakes can pass
Paris Hilton, Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and Laurel Lee are urging the US House to pass the DEFIANCE Act, which would let victims of non-consensual, AI-generated sexual deepfakes sue those who create or distribute them. They say existing protections have not kept pace with the technology and that the legislation would give victims a way to seek accountability.
Hilton described the shame and humiliation she experienced after a sex tape was leaked when she was 19, while Ocasio-Cortez said AI tools have made it easier to create abusive images from ordinary photographs. The Senate has passed the bill, but the House has made little progress since it was reintroduced in May 2025. It must pass by 3 January to avoid restarting the legislative process; the lawmakers expressed confidence in its bipartisan support.
In short
- DEFIANCE Act would let deepfake victims sue creators and distributors.
- The Senate has passed the bill; the House has yet to act.
- Supporters say bipartisan backing could help it pass by 3 January.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Supporters argue that people targeted by non-consensual sexual deepfakes deserve a practical way to seek accountability, and that existing protections have not kept pace with tools that can turn ordinary photographs into abusive images. They see a civil right to sue creators and distributors as a way to recognise victims’ harm and deter violations while upholding consent and personal dignity.
The case against
A critic could accept that the abuse is serious while questioning whether this bill is the right remedy: a new civil cause of action may add complexity to an already fragmented legal landscape, and victims may still face the costs and burdens of litigation. They may favour clearer, better-enforced existing laws or more targeted measures, and seek safeguards so liability does not chill lawful expression or sweep in people who shared material without knowing it was non-consensual.