Science news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Apple News promoted news from left-leaning outlets 71% of time, yearlong MRC study finds
The Media Research Center (MRC), a right-leaning organisation, says a year of tracking three news apps found that they promoted more stories from left-leaning than right-leaning outlets. Apple News showed the largest gap in its analysis, a finding that adds to ongoing debate about how news aggregators select and present stories.
The MRC said 71% of the 6,849 stories promoted by Apple News came from outlets AllSides rates as liberal, while about 1% came from right-leaning outlets. For Google News, it counted 239 right-leaning stories among 6,317; for Microsoft’s MSN, it reported 13% from right-leaning outlets and 53% from left-leaning ones. Google disputed the study’s methodology, saying its results change throughout the day and are personalised; Apple and Microsoft did not immediately comment.
In short
- MRC says Apple News heavily favoured left-rated outlets in its yearlong study.
- It found just 81 right-rated stories among 6,849 promoted by Apple.
- Google challenged the methodology, citing changing and personalised results.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The figures, if the outlet classifications and sampling are sound, suggest Apple News gave users far more exposure to sources rated liberal than to sources rated conservative. Such a pronounced imbalance merits scrutiny because an aggregator’s editorial choices can shape what audiences see, even without producing the stories itself.
The case against
The study’s counts may not establish systematic political bias: Google said its results vary over time and are personalised, and the summary does not show whether the sampling captured those changes or how outlets were classified. Differences in story volume, relevance or editorial standards could also explain an imbalance, so the figures alone do not show that Apple News favoured liberal coverage.
Explained simply
News apps such as Apple News, Google News and Microsoft Start gather stories from many publishers and decide which ones to show prominently. Their choices can shape what readers see, even when the apps do not report the stories themselves.
The Media Research Center is a US media-monitoring group that describes itself as conservative. AllSides is a separate organisation that rates news outlets by political leaning; such ratings are judgements about publishers, and do not by themselves establish whether an individual story is biased.
The issue matters because readers may rely on these apps to discover news, while the companies’ selection methods are not always easy to assess from outside. Comparing political labels across publishers can offer one measure, but it does not reveal why each story was selected or what users actually saw.