Apple’s HomeView has an app problem
Apple’s new HomeView has enough computing power and stays connected to power, which could make it suitable for running apps. Yet it appears to rely almost entirely on CarPlay, prompting questions about why Apple has not made the home hub its own app platform.
On The Vergecast, David and Nilay discuss the device’s app situation and Apple’s apparent choice. They also cover Google’s latest Gemini model and whether a leading AI model is enough without strong products, as well as returning to X and why alternatives to Twitter have struggled.
- HomeView appears to rely mainly on CarPlay.
- The choice raises questions about its app capabilities.
- The podcast also discusses Gemini and X.
Both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Making HomeView a platform for third-party apps could let people adapt it to their routines, add useful services and get more from hardware that is always powered and connected. An open app ecosystem might also encourage developers to build for the home, extending the device’s usefulness beyond Apple’s own features.
The case against
Keeping HomeView focused on a smaller set of functions could make it simpler to use and easier for Apple to maintain consistently, especially in a shared household. Relying on CarPlay may also offer a familiar experience while limiting the clutter, security risks and support demands that can come with a broad app platform.