Culture news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Asylum seekers returned to France describe renewed threats and abuse
Asylum seekers on what is described as the final UK-France “one in, one out” flight say they are being returned to France for a second time after fleeing threats and abuse from smugglers. Their accounts raise concerns about whether the scheme protects people from harm and whether those facing removal can access effective legal advice.
The pilot exchanged people returned to France after crossing the Channel in small boats for a similar number brought to the UK to claim asylum. Some people reportedly returned to the UK after smugglers threatened their families over crossing debts, and described being beaten, raped or forced to work in camps. A recent inspector’s report said the Home Office had not established how it would measure the scheme’s success; since it ended on 1 October, 4,786 people crossed the Channel in 69 small boats.
In short
- Some people facing removal say they returned after smugglers threatened them in France.
- Asylum seekers report difficulty accessing legal advice before deportation.
- Since the scheme ended, 4,786 people crossed in 69 small boats.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Supporters could argue that returning some people who arrived irregularly, while bringing an equivalent number to the UK through an orderly route, may deter dangerous small-boat crossings and weaken smugglers’ business. They may see the pilot as a way to manage migration while preserving a route for people to seek asylum, provided returns are lawful and safeguards work.
The case against
Critics could argue that deterrence and orderly migration cannot justify returning people to situations where they face renewed threats, abuse or exploitation, especially if they lack effective legal advice to challenge removal. The reported returns and the absence of clear measures of success raise doubts about whether the pilot was safe or effective, while the continued crossings suggest its deterrent effect is uncertain.
Explained simply
The UK-France “one in, one out” pilot linked the return of some people who crossed the Channel in small boats to France with the admission of a similar number to the UK to claim asylum. It was intended to discourage dangerous crossings by making return a possible outcome.
The scheme involved the UK Home Office, which handles immigration and asylum, and French authorities. People who cross the Channel may also depend on smugglers, and some have said smugglers threatened or abused them over debts or other disputes.
The case raises questions about how authorities assess risks to people sent back to France and whether they can get legal advice before removal. An inspector also found that the Home Office had not set out how it would measure the pilot’s success.
Culture Europe Politics Travel UK World
Read the full article at the source →
Originally published by The Guardian as “Asylum seekers on final ‘one in, one out’ UK-France flight feel they are being ‘punished’”.