Beast of Reincarnation is a Pokémon-inspired soulslike without the cruelty of Dark Souls – and it’s better for it
GamesRadar argues that Beast of Reincarnation borrows the precise, parry-focused combat associated with soulslike games while avoiding their most punishing conventions. The article presents this as a significant choice because it could make Game Freak’s new action RPG more welcoming without removing the satisfaction of mastering difficult encounters.
The game follows Emma and her dog Koo through a corrupted, post-apocalyptic Japan, with Koo central to both the story and combat. Unlike a conventional soulslike, it offers difficulty settings, follows a linear structure rather than an open world, and has no online elements; successful parries help enable Koo’s special attacks.
In short
- Soulslike-style combat without the usual harshness
- Difficulty settings make it more approachable
- Emma and Koo fight through corrupted Japan
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Soulslike games derive their satisfaction from mastering precise, demanding mechanics—parrying, dodging, reading enemy patterns—rather than from punishing death penalties. By retaining the skill-based combat whilst offering difficulty settings and removing features like harsh resurrection costs or permanent progress loss, Beast of Reincarnation preserves what makes the genre compelling whilst making quality challenge genuinely accessible. This represents better design: challenge and consequence need not be synonymous.
The case against
The harsh punishment systems—permadeath elements, lost progress, unforgiving checkpoints—are integral to soulslikes because they create genuine psychological weight and investment. Removing cruelty eliminates the tension that makes victory feel truly earned and the world feel genuinely threatening; the game becomes merely a challenging action RPG rather than a soulslike experience. Consequence and difficulty are inseparable; strip away punishment and you strip away what makes the genre distinctive.
Explained simply
A soulslike is an action game built around demanding fights, where players learn enemy attack patterns and time their defences carefully. The genre is often associated with high difficulty and repeated attempts, though games can vary in how punishing they are.
Beast of Reincarnation is an action role-playing game from Game Freak, the studio best known for Pokémon. It follows Emma and her dog Koo through a corrupted, post-apocalyptic Japan; Koo also fights alongside Emma, with well-timed parries helping to trigger his special attacks.
The game combines precise combat with a linear story and difficulty settings, and has no online features. These choices shape how players encounter its challenges and distinguish its structure from many games in the soulslike genre.
Entertainment Gaming Software Technology