Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Game Freak’s post-apocalyptic action RPG borrows heavily but still impresses
Developed over time first seen 3 months ago
Eurogamer has reviewed Beast of Reincarnation, the latest project from Pokémon developer Game Freak, describing it as a chaotic blend of borrowed ideas that ultimately proves engaging thanks to strong combat and traversal. The action RPG draws heavily on other major titles, mixing Sekiro-style parrying and respawn checkpoints, Monster Hunter and Shadow of the Colossus-style boss hunts, and visual echoes of Horizon's post-apocalyptic aesthetic, meaning it initially struggles to establish its own identity. This matters because it marks a notable departure for Game Freak, better known for Pokémon, into a mature, combat-focused action genre.
The game is set in a post-apocalyptic Japan in the year 4026, where humanity has abandoned emotion and, in some cases, physical bodies, transferring souls into robotic golems, while a mysterious blight turns creatures into hostile "Malefacts". Players control Emma, a hunter without heart or soul, who must track down and slay towering region-ruling beasts called Nushi across a linear but visually striking landscape of overgrown cities, rural ruins and mountain temples. The review notes the muddled, erratically paced story and poorly explained systems hamper the opening hours, but the exhilarating combat and traversal ultimately give the game a surprising amount of soul.
- Sources
- 2
- Outlets
- 2
- Left · Centre · Right
- 0 · 0 · 0
In short
- Eurogamer reviews Game Freak's Beast of Reincarnation, an action RPG departure from Pokémon
- Borrows heavily from Sekiro, Monster Hunter, Shadow of the Colossus and Horizon
- Muddled story and systems, but combat and traversal salvage the experience
How this story developed
- 3 months ago Eurogamer's coverage was refined to describe Emma's soulless hunt across a series of semi-open regions rather than a single linear world, and to clarify that the game's early hours overwhelm players with rushed lore and systems before the mechanics click and the experience improves.
- 3 months ago Eurogamer published its review of Beast of Reincarnation, Game Freak's departure from Pokémon into an action RPG borrowing Sekiro parrying, Monster Hunter and Shadow of the Colossus boss fights, and a Horizon-esque post-apocalyptic Japan of 4026, judging its opening hours muddled but its combat and traversal ultimately rewarding as Emma hunts the towering Nushi.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
A game's value is determined by the quality of its execution and how much enjoyment it delivers to players, not the originality of its inspirational sources. Many celebrated titles build upon proven formulas from other games. Game Freak has successfully synthesised elements from acclaimed predecessors into an engaging experience with demonstrably strong combat and traversal mechanics. The meaningful engagement that emerges from excellent mechanical design is what players ultimately remember, and this game appears to deliver precisely that achievement despite its derivative conceptual foundations.
The case against
A studio of Game Freak's stature and resources bears responsibility to innovate and create original experiences rather than merely reassembling borrowed mechanics from other titles. The game's struggle to establish its own identity, compounded by muddled storytelling and poorly explained systems, suggests that relying on familiar frameworks prevented the developers from crafting something truly cohesive and distinctive. In an industry increasingly crowded with genuine innovation, a largely derivative action RPG—regardless of its mechanical proficiency—represents a squandered opportunity for meaningful creative contribution from an established studio.
Explained simply
Video games hold souls, robots, and monster hunts — the terms of Game Freak's setup are as much for context as the review verdict.
Game Freak is best known as the studio behind Pokémon, one of the biggest video game franchises in the world. Beast of Reincarnation is a new project from the same developer, but it moves into a very different area: a mature, combat-heavy action role-playing game rather than the family-friendly monster-collecting formula it usually makes. The game has just been reviewed by the gaming website Eurogamer, whose verdict is what the story reports on.
The game borrows heavily from other well-known titles. It takes its combat style from Sekiro, its boss-hunting structure from Monster Hunter and Shadow of the Colossus, and some of its visual style from Horizon's ruined-world settings. It is set in a version of Japan far in the future, where people have given up emotion and, in some cases, their human bodies, moving their minds into robotic frames, while monstrous creatures called Nushi roam the land.
Coverage · 2 sources
Read the full article at the source →
Originally published by Eurogamer as “Beast of Reincarnation review – Game Freak riffs on Sekiro and Monster Hunter with mixed results”.