World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Beijing ranked its guests in Shenzhen. Putin came second, and so does his bluff
Xi Jinping gave Donald Trump a more prominent welcome in Shenzhen than Vladimir Putin, greeting Trump at Air Force One while Putin was met by Xi’s chief of staff. The contrast in protocol and their places at an APEC leaders’ photo offered a public indication of Beijing’s relative treatment of the two visitors.
Putin arrived several hours before Trump and was welcomed by Cai Qi, a senior Communist Party official, but not by Xi. At the leaders’ photo, footage showed Xi directing Putin to his place, with Xi’s wife between them and Trump beside Xi. The article says the images prompted comparisons online, though it gives no further details about the meetings.
In short
- Xi greeted Trump at the aircraft stairs in Shenzhen.
- Putin was welcomed by Xi’s chief of staff.
- Their positions at the APEC photo drew attention.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The difference in protocol can reasonably be read as a deliberate signal that Beijing values its relationship with Trump and sees him as the more consequential guest. Public welcomes and seating arrangements are tools of diplomacy, and Xi’s personal greeting and Trump’s position beside him may indicate a wish to cultivate influence with Washington.
The case against
Protocol and photo positions are ambiguous evidence of Beijing’s priorities: they can reflect scheduling, logistics, or the conventions of a particular event rather than a considered ranking of leaders. Putin’s earlier arrival and the limited details about either meeting make it difficult to infer that the staging represented a substantive downgrade or that it revealed anything decisive about his leverage.
Asia Government Politics World