Beverly Hills school board candidate under fire over messages mocking trustee’s visit to Jewish holy site
Screenshots from a private group chat, attributed to Beverly Hills school board candidate Kim Lifschitz, appear to mock trustee Russell Stuart’s visit to Jerusalem’s Western Wall and his wearing of a kippah. Stuart said the remarks ridicule Jewish religious observance, while Lifschitz denied making antisemitic comments and said her criticism was about what she saw as Stuart using religious symbols for political purposes.
A further screenshot appears to mock board vice-president Sigalie Sabag for discussing Holocaust survivors who spoke with district pupils. Lifschitz said she is Jewish and has experienced antisemitism herself; she described the messages as nearly a year old. California GOP Jewish Engagement Chair Elizabeth Barcohana also criticised Lifschitz’s candidacy. The article mentions a separate controversy involving comments by Lifschitz’s husband on a livestream by Hasan Piker, but the supplied text gives no further details.
In short
- Screenshots attributed to Kim Lifschitz drew accusations of antisemitism.
- Russell Stuart said the messages mocked his religious observance.
- Lifschitz denied antisemitism and said she was criticising political use of symbols.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Critics of Lifschitz may argue that mocking a trustee’s visit to the Western Wall and his wearing of a kippah, alongside remarks about a colleague discussing Holocaust survivors, risks trivialising Jewish faith and memory. They may see the messages as raising legitimate questions about whether she can represent a diverse school community with respect, regardless of her own identity or intent.
The case against
Lifschitz’s strongest defence is that she says her criticism concerned what she viewed as a trustee using religious symbols for political purposes, rather than Jewish observance itself. She also denies antisemitic intent, identifies as Jewish, says she has experienced antisemitism, and notes that the messages are nearly a year old; voters may weigh that explanation and context before judging her fitness as a candidate.