Health news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Call for police to investigate Scottish hospital after 19 deaths due to surgery
A senior surgeon has called for a police investigation into Aberdeen Royal Infirmary after an internal review found that 19 patients died following avoidable surgical complications. Dr Mohammed Habib says he repeatedly raised concerns from 2021 onwards and alleges NHS Grampian did not act quickly enough; the case has prompted calls for answers and justice for patients’ families.
Two external experts found that the death rate for liver and pancreatic surgery at the hospital reached as high as 18% between 2017 and 2020, compared with a national average of 2–3%, depending on patients’ conditions. Habib later reported four further deaths, and an expert warned in March 2026 of persistent high mortality and systemic failure; the department has since closed. First Minister John Swinney said the disclosures were of the gravest concern but rejected demands for a criminal investigation, while NHS Grampian said it would consider any new evidence.
In short
- Review linked 19 deaths to avoidable surgical complications.
- Mortality reached 18%, against a 2–3% national average.
- Aberdeen’s liver and pancreatic surgery department has closed.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
A police investigation could establish whether the deaths involved conduct that warrants criminal scrutiny, independently test the evidence and give families a route to answers. Given the reported gap between the hospital’s mortality rates and national averages, and claims that concerns were raised repeatedly, advocates argue that an independent investigation is justified to determine whether failures were preventable and who was responsible.
The case against
The deaths and reported safety failures demand a thorough response, but a criminal investigation should depend on evidence of possible criminal conduct, not the seriousness of the outcome alone. Advocates of relying first on clinical, regulatory and public inquiries argue these can examine systemic failings and individual decisions in context, while police involvement without a clear criminal basis could duplicate that work or prejudice it.
Explained simply
Aberdeen Royal Infirmary is a major hospital run by NHS Grampian, the health board serving north-east Scotland. Its liver and pancreatic surgery unit treated people with serious illnesses, and the risks of these operations can vary with a patient’s condition.
A review by two outside experts found that 19 patients died after complications they judged avoidable, and reported death rates well above the national average. Surgeon Mohammed Habib says he raised concerns from 2021; the department has since closed, and NHS Grampian is responsible for hospital services in the area.
The case matters because it raises questions about how concerns about patient safety were handled and what families can expect by way of answers. Police investigations assess whether a crime may have occurred, while health-service reviews examine care and the systems around it.