World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Charter school network files First Amendment lawsuit after state blocks AP scores from US News
Success Academy, New York City's largest charter school network, has filed a federal First Amendment lawsuit against New York State Education Commissioner Betty A. Rosa, accusing the state of unlawfully blocking the release of students' Advanced Placement exam results to U.S. News & World Report for its annual high school rankings. The network's attorney, Eric Grannis, argues that withholding this data prevents the publication of truthful, independently verified information and represents a clear violation of publication rights, particularly since AP data has been shared for such rankings for decades without issue.
Because the state declined to authorise the College Board to release 2026 AP scores, U.S. News based its advanced-course rankings solely on International Baccalaureate data, a metric Success Academy does not offer, causing its statewide ranking to plunge from 11th to 196th. The network says this obscures strong results, noting that 95% of its 2026 graduating class passed three or more AP exams and 60% passed seven or more, compared with a national AP pass rate below 25%. Founded in 2006, Success Academy educates over 22,000 mostly low-income, Black and Hispanic students and has previously outperformed wealthier districts like Scarsdale in state maths and English tests. NYSED has defended its stance by citing student data privacy laws and opposition to commercialising student information.
In short
- Success Academy sues NY education chief over blocked AP exam data.
- State barred College Board sharing scores with U.S. News rankings.
- Network's ranking fell from 11th to 196th as a result.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Success Academy can argue that AP results are factual, independently verified measures of academic achievement, and that withholding them prevents families and the public from making informed comparisons. The network also says the data has long been released for rankings and that excluding AP scores materially misrepresents schools that do not offer International Baccalaureate courses, raising a serious question about whether the state is restricting lawful publication.
The case against
The state can argue that it has a duty to protect students’ privacy and to prevent their educational records from being used in commercial rankings without adequate safeguards or authorisation. It may also contend that disclosure rules should be set consistently for all schools, and that a publisher’s ranking methodology does not outweigh the state’s responsibility to control how sensitive student data is shared.
Explained simply
Advanced Placement (AP) exams are US high-school courses and tests that can earn students college credit. U.S. News & World Report uses schools’ results in its annual rankings, while New York’s education department oversees the state’s education system and controls access to some student data.
Success Academy is a network of publicly funded charter schools, which are independently run but subject to state rules. It serves more than 22,000 pupils in New York City, many from low-income families. International Baccalaureate is another advanced study programme, but Success Academy does not offer it.
The dispute raises questions about how schools’ results can be shared and used in rankings, and how student privacy should be protected. It also matters because rankings can affect how families compare schools, while schools and publishers may rely on access to exam data to describe academic performance.