Politics news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Clarence Thomas calls foul on California ruling he says could turn citizens into government mouthpieces
The Supreme Court declined to hear a California doctor’s challenge to a state requirement that continuing medical education courses cover implicit bias. Justice Clarence Thomas, joined by Justice Samuel Alito, dissented, warning that the ruling could leave states able to require private speakers to convey government-backed views without First Amendment scrutiny.
California requires licensed doctors to complete 50 hours of approved education every two years, with courses addressing implicit bias and health disparities. Dr Azadeh Khatibi and the group Do No Harm argued the requirement forces instructors to include a topic they dispute; California said instructors can question the theory and explain that it is included to meet state rules. A federal appeals court classified the courses as government speech, while Thomas warned that this reasoning could extend to other licensed professions.
In short
- The Supreme Court declined to hear a doctor’s free-speech challenge.
- California requires approved medical courses to address implicit bias.
- Thomas warned the reasoning could affect speakers in other professions.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
California can argue that continuing education is a regulated part of medical licensing, and that addressing implicit bias and health disparities helps doctors understand factors that may affect patient care. The state says instructors remain free to question the underlying ideas, while explaining that the topic is included to meet course requirements; treating approved courses as government speech can preserve the state’s ability to set those requirements.
The case against
Critics can argue that requiring instructors to cover a state-selected topic risks compelling private speakers to present views they dispute, even if they may also criticise them. They contend that classifying the courses as government speech could weaken First Amendment scrutiny and allow similar requirements to spread across licensed professions.
Explained simply
California requires licensed doctors to complete 50 hours of approved continuing education every two years. Some courses must address implicit bias, the idea that unconscious assumptions can affect how people treat others, and health disparities.
Dr Azadeh Khatibi and Do No Harm challenged the requirement, arguing that it pressures course instructors to teach a subject they dispute. The state says instructors may question the theory and explain that the topic is included to meet California’s rules.
The First Amendment protects freedom of speech and can limit when government may control what people say. The dispute centres on whether the courses count as speech by the state or by private instructors, a distinction that could affect how similar requirements for other licensed professions are treated.