Business news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Closer ties to the EU will do nothing to bring down energy costs
The article argues that Prime Minister Andy Burnham’s proposed link between the UK and EU emissions trading schemes would raise energy costs rather than reduce them. It says the government should instead remove domestic carbon levies, presenting this as a way to ease household bills and support economic growth.
The article cites Prosperity Institute calculations that linking the schemes could raise UK carbon prices by about 32 per cent. It says scrapping the Climate Change Levy, Carbon Price Support, the UK emissions trading scheme and the proposed UK carbon border measure could cut energy users’ bills by £7.2 billion a year, including about £60 off household bills, at a stated Exchequer cost of £4.2 billion.
In short
- The article says linking UK and EU carbon markets could raise energy costs.
- It estimates UK carbon prices could rise by about 32 per cent.
- It argues abolishing domestic carbon levies could cut energy costs.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Supporters of linking the UK and EU emissions trading schemes could argue that closer alignment would make carbon pricing more predictable for businesses trading across borders and help coordinate efforts to cut emissions. They may accept that the carbon price could rise, but argue that a consistent market can support investment in cleaner energy and that targeted help is preferable to removing carbon levies, whose costs are intended to reflect pollution.
The case against
Opponents could argue that linking the schemes may expose UK energy users to higher carbon prices without a clear guarantee of lower bills or faster emissions cuts. They may favour removing or reducing domestic levies to ease household and business costs, support growth and competitiveness, while accepting the stated Exchequer cost as a trade-off.
Business Climate Europe Government Politics Science UK World