World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Columbia’s gates will remain closed to NYC locals, judge rules
A Manhattan judge has dismissed Morningside Heights residents’ lawsuit seeking to reopen Columbia University’s College Walk to the public. The ruling lets the university keep its gates closed, while residents’ lawyer says they plan to appeal.
College Walk runs through campus on West 116th Street and was once used by students and the public as a shortcut. Columbia closed its gates after protests in October 2023 and kept them shut following 2024 campus demonstrations; entry now requires a university ID. Residents argued a 1953 agreement with the city guaranteed public access and that the closure disadvantages older and disabled neighbours, but the judge found no such right in the agreement. Mayor Zohra Mamdani had threatened legal action in September, while Columbia welcomed the ruling’s recognition of the path as private property.
In short
- A judge ruled Columbia can keep College Walk closed to the public.
- Residents say they will appeal the decision.
- The court found the 1953 agreement did not guarantee access.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Columbia can argue that the judge found no public-access right in the 1953 agreement, and that the university should be able to control entry to property it owns. Keeping the gates closed also gives it greater control over campus security after demonstrations, while allowing access to people with university IDs.
The case against
Residents can argue that College Walk served as a longstanding public shortcut and that closing it burdens neighbours, especially older and disabled people. They contend the 1953 agreement supports continued public access, and that the judge’s interpretation should be challenged on appeal.
Explained simply
College Walk is a pedestrian route through Columbia University’s campus in Morningside Heights, Manhattan. For years, students and local residents used it as a shortcut across West 116th Street.
Columbia University is a private university, and it closed its campus gates after protests in 2023 and 2024. Since then, people have needed a university ID to enter, affecting neighbours who used the route, including older and disabled residents.
The dispute centres on whether a 1953 agreement between Columbia and New York City guaranteed public access to the path. The disagreement matters because it concerns how the university’s campus is used and what access local residents can expect.