Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Columbus coach says ‘eveyone knows’ Lionel Messi dodged red card after throwing ball into opponent’s face in Miami playoff loss
Columbus Crew coach Laurent Courtois said Lionel Messi should have been sent off after throwing the ball into Gonzalo Tapia’s face during Columbus’s 3-0 win over Inter Miami. Referee Allen Chapman cautioned both players, leaving Messi available for the next match in the best-of-three playoff series.
The incident came in first-half stoppage time with Columbus leading 1-0; Tapia had not stood the required two yards from the throw-in and later scored twice. Courtois said the contact merited more than a yellow card, while Tapia and Miami coach Kily Gonzalez declined to challenge the referee’s decision. Miami, the defending MLS Cup champions, now face elimination; Messi finished the regular season with 26 goals and 17 assists.
In short
- Columbus beat Miami 3-0 in their playoff opener.
- Courtois said Messi should have received a red card.
- Miami must win the next game to avoid elimination.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Courtois’s case is that deliberately throwing the ball into an opponent’s face is violent conduct and should merit a red card, regardless of whether the contact caused injury. A dismissal would apply the rules consistently and deter players from using the ball to target opponents; the fact that Tapia was too close to the throw-in would not justify that response.
The case against
The referee saw the incident in real time and cautioned both players, while Tapia and Miami’s coach did not dispute the decision. The proximity at the throw-in may have contributed to the confrontation, and the account does not establish how forceful the contact was or whether it was judged deliberate enough to warrant a sending-off; a yellow card can be defended as a proportionate response to an ambiguous incident.
Explained simply
Major League Soccer (MLS) is the top professional football league in the United States and Canada. Its teams compete for the MLS Cup, with the play-offs deciding the champion; this series is being played as a best-of-three, so the first team to win two matches advances.
Inter Miami, whose captain is Argentina forward Lionel Messi, won the previous season’s MLS Cup. Columbus Crew are another MLS club, and their coach is Laurent Courtois. In football, referees can caution players with a yellow card or send them off with a red card, which means they must leave the match.
The outcome of a referee’s decision can affect who is available for later matches, as well as the current game. Miami’s status as defending champions and Messi’s scoring record have drawn attention to the team’s play-off campaign.