Science news and discussion on TalkFuse.
‘Complete extermination’ of greys is the only way to protect red squirrels
A grey squirrel control co-ordinator in the Scottish Borders has said that only the complete extermination of grey squirrels can protect native red squirrels from squirrelpox, a virus that is deadly to reds but merely carried by greys. Bill Ferguson of the Central Borders Red Squirrel Network made the comments after several cases of the disease were confirmed in the Borders and other parts of Scotland in recent weeks, arguing there is no vaccine or alternative measure that can save red squirrels while greys remain in the area.
Ferguson said trapping and killing grey squirrels, described as humane, was currently the only option, though a contraceptive for greys is being developed that could eventually let them "die off naturally". He also urged the public to remove and disinfect bird feeders used by both species for around three weeks, and called on estate owners to help control grey squirrel numbers. Grey squirrels were introduced to Britain from North America in the 19th century, and critics of culling note that squirrelpox is one of several similar diseases affecting reds, and that reds are more likely to catch it from each other than from greys.
In short
- Expert says exterminating grey squirrels is only way to stop squirrelpox
- Squirrelpox is deadly to red squirrels but carried harmlessly by greys
- Public urged to remove and disinfect shared bird feeders for three weeks
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Red squirrels are a native British species facing extinction from a lethal disease carried by introduced grey squirrels, against which there is currently no vaccine or cure. Advocates for culling argue that when an invasive species introduces a novel pathogen that threatens an irreplaceable native population, selective removal becomes a justified conservation measure to restore ecological balance, particularly given that greys have no practical alternative habitat and contraceptive programmes remain years away from viability.
The case against
Culling raises substantial ethical concerns about mass killing, and the underlying science may not support such an extreme response. Red squirrels contract squirrelpox through multiple transmission routes including from each other, meaning complete grey extermination is unlikely to eliminate the disease threat; resources would be better directed toward developing effective vaccines, contraceptive technologies, and habitat management that address the disease itself rather than pursuing what amounts to species elimination as a blunt tool for managing complex ecological problems.
Explained simply
Britain has two squirrel species: red squirrels, which are native, and grey squirrels, introduced from North America in the 1800s. Squirrelpox is a virus that kills red squirrels but does not seriously harm greys, which can carry and spread the disease.
Red squirrel populations have declined across much of Britain, partly because of squirrelpox outbreaks. Recent cases of the virus have been reported in Scotland, prompting concerns about the future of red squirrels in affected areas.
Managing squirrelpox in wild populations is complicated because greys can carry the disease while remaining unaffected themselves. This has led to ongoing discussions about how best to protect red squirrels whilst dealing with the presence of grey squirrels.