Politics news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Confidence in Hormuz has been ‘crushed’ by war on Iran, IEA says
Fatih Birol, head of the International Energy Agency (IEA), said the war on Iran has severely damaged confidence in the Strait of Hormuz as a safe route for energy exports. He warned that shipping could be disrupted again and said he sees no credible way back to the situation before the war, raising the prospect of lasting changes to energy trade.
The IEA said alternative pipelines around the strait would cost about $40 billion and add roughly $2 to the price of each exported barrel of oil; developing energy sources outside the Middle East could require another $200 billion. Projects under way or considered could carry about seven million barrels of oil a day, potentially cutting transit through Hormuz to two million barrels a day by 2035 under the IEA’s low-transit scenario. The agency cautioned that pipelines and other routes could also be vulnerable to attack.
In short
- The war has undermined confidence in Hormuz as an energy corridor.
- Bypassing the strait could require $40 billion in pipelines.
- Alternative routes would still face security risks.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The war has shown that reliance on the Strait of Hormuz exposes energy supplies to renewed disruption, so investing in pipelines and energy sources elsewhere could improve resilience and reduce the risk of future price shocks. The high upfront costs may be justified if they provide more dependable routes and supply over the long term.
The case against
The proposed alternatives would require substantial investment and could add costs to exported oil, while pipelines and other routes would remain vulnerable to attack. A critic could argue that diverting resources from existing trade routes risks making energy more expensive without removing the underlying security threats, and that restoring stability around Hormuz may be a more practical priority.
Explained simply
The Strait of Hormuz is a narrow sea passage between Iran and Oman, linking the Gulf to the wider ocean. Oil and gas from several Gulf countries pass through it, making it one of the world’s main routes for energy exports.
Iran lies beside the strait, while countries including Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates export energy from the Gulf. The International Energy Agency is an organisation that monitors energy markets and advises governments. Some exporters have considered pipelines and other routes that would let more oil bypass the strait.
The route matters because disruption can affect how much energy reaches buyers and how much it costs. Pipelines could reduce reliance on ships passing through Hormuz, but they require large investments and may also be vulnerable to attack.
Government Middle East Politics World