Culture news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Costco shoppers want beloved $4.99 food court sandwich back years after it disappeared
Some Costco shoppers are still asking for the return of the warehouse chain’s barbecue beef brisket sandwich, years after it left food courts. The renewed discussion shows how a low-cost menu item can build a loyal following, even though customers did not all enjoy it.
The sandwich combined shredded beef, barbecue sauce and creamy coleslaw in a bun, and sold for $4.99 after appearing at some locations from around 2013. Costco reportedly began removing it from some food courts in 2018, and it had disappeared by about 2020; no verified reason for its removal has been given. Posts on Reddit in 2019, 2025 and 2026 recall the sandwich, while some customers criticised its sweetness and the beef’s texture.
In short
- The $4.99 brisket sandwich is still missed by some Costco shoppers.
- It combined shredded beef, barbecue sauce and coleslaw.
- It disappeared from food courts around 2020.
Explained simply
Costco is a membership warehouse chain that also runs food courts, where shoppers can buy inexpensive meals. Its barbecue beef brisket sandwich appeared at some locations from around 2013, combining shredded beef, barbecue sauce and coleslaw in a bun.
The sandwich cost $4.99 and was gradually removed from food courts from 2018; it had disappeared by about 2020. Some customers remember it fondly, while others disliked its sweetness or the texture of the beef, and no verified reason for its removal has been given.
The discussion shows how a low-priced menu item can attract loyal customers even when opinions differ. Costco’s food court is part of the shopping experience for many members, so changes to its menu can prompt lasting interest.