Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Councillors clash over taking credit for resurfacing ‘atrocious’ road – thestar.co.uk
Two Sheffield councillors have publicly disagreed over who deserves credit for resurfacing Myrtle Road in Heeley, after residents had long complained the road was in an "atrocious" state due to extensive potholes. Reform councillor Matt Smith, newly elected in May for the Park and Arbourthorne ward, said he had pushed for the repairs throughout the summer but was not notified when the work went ahead, and was angered after seeing footage of Labour councillor Ben Miskell at the site, which he felt amounted to Miskell claiming credit for his efforts.
Miskell rejected the criticism, saying the resurfacing project predated Smith's election and that he had been liaising with contractor Amey since March, with notices posted on local lampposts ahead of the works. He suggested Smith would have known about the project had he been "out and about" in the ward, while thanking him for "sending a few emails." Council officers said the failure to notify Smith directly was down to an administrative oversight.
In short
- Sheffield councillors Matt Smith and Ben Miskell dispute credit for fixing Myrtle Road.
- Smith (Reform) says he wasn't told repairs were happening despite pushing for them.
- Miskell (Labour) says the project began before Smith's election.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Smith can reasonably argue that, as the newly elected councillor for the ward, he pressed for repairs residents urgently needed and should have been kept informed when the work took place. Appearing at the site without acknowledging his efforts could give residents an incomplete picture of how their concerns were acted on, especially when the council accepts that it failed to notify him directly.
The case against
Miskell can reasonably argue that the project was already under way before Smith’s election and that his own liaison with the contractor helped move it forward. Notices were posted locally, and the council describes the lack of direct notification as an administrative oversight, so Miskell may see his visit as reporting on work he had been involved in rather than taking credit from Smith.
Explained simply
Sheffield’s council is responsible for maintaining local roads, including filling potholes and arranging larger resurfacing projects. Myrtle Road is in Heeley, within the Park and Arbourthorne ward, which is represented by councillors from different political parties.
Councillors can raise residents’ concerns with council officers and contractors, and may seek to show what they have done for their area. Resurfacing projects can take time to plan, so the work may have been arranged before the councillor who later raises the issue was elected.
Celebrity Entertainment Sheffield UK World