Politics news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Cruz and Cornyn at odds over judicial vacancy in Texas
Senator Ted Cruz is urging Senator John Cornyn to back President Donald Trump’s nominee, T. Elliot Gaiser, for a federal judgeship in Dallas. The dispute matters because the nomination faces a tight deadline: Republicans are due to lose control of the Senate in January, which could change who has influence over the vacancy.
Cornyn is instead pressing the White House to nominate Steve Fahey, a Fort Worth lawyer. Cruz describes Gaiser, who leads the Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel and previously clerked for the Supreme Court, as exceptionally well qualified and the only candidate who could be confirmed before the change in Senate control. If the seat remains vacant, incoming Democratic Senator James Talarico could gain influence over its future.
In short
- Cruz backs Gaiser for a Dallas judgeship.
- Cornyn is urging Trump to choose Fahey.
- A January vacancy could give Talarico influence.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Cruz’s case is that Gaiser’s senior Justice Department role and Supreme Court clerkship make him exceptionally qualified, and the approaching change in Senate control makes prompt confirmation important. Leaving the seat vacant could give the incoming senator more influence over the eventual choice, so backing the nominee now may preserve the current Senate’s ability to fill it.
The case against
Cornyn’s case is that the White House should consider Fahey, a Fort Worth lawyer, for the vacancy rather than commit to Gaiser. A tight deadline alone need not settle who is best suited for the judgeship; the choice should allow a considered assessment of the candidates and the views of those who will represent Texas as the vacancy is filled.
Explained simply
Federal judges are nominated by the president and must be approved by the Senate. A vacancy on a federal court can remain open until a nominee wins enough support in the Senate, and the balance of power there can affect how quickly that happens.
Ted Cruz and John Cornyn are both Republican senators from Texas, but they do not agree on whom the White House should nominate for a judgeship in Dallas. T. Elliot Gaiser leads a Justice Department legal office and has previously worked for the Supreme Court; Steve Fahey is a lawyer based in Fort Worth.
The timing matters because Republicans are expected to lose their Senate majority in January. If the seat is still vacant after the change, the incoming senator from Texas, Democrat James Talarico, could have a say in who is considered next.