Cummins concerns and weaknesses to target – takeaways from SA-Australia
South Africa beat Australia in the final Test to win an enthralling series, reclaim the top spot in the Test rankings and underline their strength ahead of England’s winter tour. The result also exposed questions about Australia’s ageing attack and captain Pat Cummins’s form, while offering England clues about where South Africa can be challenged.
Cummins went more than 62 overs between wickets and averaged 53.66 with the ball, although his expected-wickets figures suggest he bowled better than those numbers show. In Cape Town, off-spinner Simon Harmer took 10-120 on a turning pitch, and South African captain Temba Bavuma was dismissed by off-spin in four of five innings. South Africa also lost seven wickets to short balls in the third Test, another potential avenue for England to explore.
In short
- South Africa beat Australia and regained the top Test ranking.
- Cummins’s form and Australia’s ageing attack face scrutiny.
- Harmer’s ten wickets point to spin as a possible route for England.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Cummins’s wicket drought and high bowling average raise legitimate questions about whether Australia’s ageing attack can maintain its effectiveness, even if expected-wickets figures suggest some misfortune. South Africa’s success against off-spin and short-pitched bowling also gives England evidence-based tactics to test their opponents, while recognising that conditions and execution will matter.
The case against
A short run of results can overstate a decline: expected-wickets figures indicate Cummins may have bowled better than his returns suggest, and one series cannot settle whether Australia’s attack is ageing out. South Africa’s vulnerabilities to off-spin and short balls are useful clues, but they do not guarantee England success, since the pitches, batters’ responses and bowlers’ execution may differ.
Explained simply
Test cricket is played over up to five days, with each team batting twice. South Africa and Australia are established international sides, and their series results affect the Test rankings. Pat Cummins is Australia’s fast-bowling captain; Simon Harmer is a South African off-spinner, while Temba Bavuma leads South Africa’s team.
England are due to tour South Africa in the winter, so the series may offer clues about the conditions and tactics they could face. Spinners can be especially influential on turning pitches, while short-pitched bowling is another way to challenge batters. A team’s age and form can also shape questions about how its bowling attack will fare in future matches.
Africa Entertainment Sport TV UK World