World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
David Bednar’s looming $23 million decision comes with few Yankees backup options
The Yankees face a Tuesday deadline to learn whether closer David Bednar will accept their one-year, $23.15 million qualifying offer or test free agency. His choice matters as the club rebuilds much of its bullpen: if he declines, the Yankees can still try to re-sign him, but will compete with other teams and may need to offer a multi-year contract.
Bednar, 32, recorded a 2.39 ERA and 45 saves in 86 appearances for the Yankees, then allowed one run over nine playoff innings. His performance and leadership helped a bullpen that had a 3.13 ERA, second-best in the majors last season. A possible contract baseline is Devin Williams’s three-year, $51 million deal; if Bednar leaves, the Yankees could look at Adrian Morejon or a trade for Trevor Megill. They have agreed to bring back Tim Hill on a one-year, $2.25 million deal, with a $2.5 million club option for 2028.
In short
- Bednar must decide on the Yankees’ $23.15 million qualifying offer by Tuesday.
- He could seek a multi-year deal after a strong season and playoffs.
- The Yankees have few obvious bullpen alternatives.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Accepting the qualifying offer would give Bednar a substantial one-year salary while allowing him to build on a strong season and return to a team where he has already proved effective. For the Yankees, retaining a proven closer would bring stability to a bullpen they are otherwise rebuilding, and could be preferable to competing for him later or relying on less certain alternatives.
The case against
Declining could let Bednar seek a longer contract that reflects his performance, leadership and value to a club in need of a closer. The Yankees could reasonably prefer to preserve flexibility rather than commit more years and money, trusting that options such as Morejon, Megill or other available relievers can help rebuild the bullpen.