World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Dead Melbourne Cup racehorse found dumped in bin
So You Are, a five-year-old racehorse that finished eighth in the Melbourne Cup, was found dead in an industrial rubbish bin near Sydney two weeks after the race. The discovery has prompted an investigation and criticism over how the horse’s remains were handled.
Trainer Bjorn Baker said he was deeply distressed and expected a full explanation. Equine hospital REC Equine Specialists apologised, saying a contracted provider took the euthanised horse to a licensed landfill and that he should have been buried promptly and respectfully. Racing NSW said landfill is the preferred option after euthanasia because of the chemicals involved, but said the burial should have been handled with dignity and vowed to act if its investigation finds wrongdoing.
In short
- Melbourne Cup horse So You Are was found in an industrial bin.
- The horse was euthanised after severe colic.
- Racing NSW is investigating the handling of his remains.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Racing NSW’s position is that landfill disposal can be the safer practical option after euthanasia because of the chemicals used, and may be handled through licensed facilities. On this view, the key failure was not the disposal method itself but the apparent delay and lack of dignity in handling the remains, which an investigation should clarify.
The case against
Those responsible for the horse’s care had a duty to ensure his remains were treated promptly and respectfully, regardless of the disposal method. Finding him in an industrial bin two weeks later raises legitimate questions about whether that duty was met and whether oversight of the contracted provider was adequate.