World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Dear Abby: I have dementia and don’t know how to tell my 91-year-old mom
A person recently diagnosed with dementia asks Dear Abby whether to tell their 91-year-old mother, who has already lost two children to cancer in the past five years. Abby advises sharing the diagnosis directly, on the son’s own terms, so his mother can support him rather than finding out after an awkward incident.
The column also responds to two family dilemmas. Abby suggests a wife introduce herself when her husband fails to introduce her to his old friends, and urges an unhappy uncle to congratulate his pregnant niece and decide whether to attend family gatherings with a more welcoming attitude.
In short
- Dear Abby advises telling a 91-year-old mother about a dementia diagnosis.
- The mother has lost two children to cancer in five years.
- Abby also addresses introductions and tensions over a new baby.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Telling his mother directly could respect her right to know and give them a chance to talk, plan and support one another while he can explain the diagnosis in his own words. A calm, honest conversation may also prevent her learning about it unexpectedly or misinterpreting symptoms.
The case against
Given her age and the recent deaths of two children, he may reasonably worry that the news would cause her serious distress without giving her much ability to help. He could choose to wait, share the information gradually or first seek advice from someone who knows her health and circumstances, while recognising that keeping it private may also limit their time to discuss it together.
Explained simply
Dementia is a term for conditions that affect memory, thinking and everyday activities; it is not a normal part of ageing. A diagnosis can raise questions about how and when to tell family members, especially when they are already coping with loss.
Dear Abby is an advice column in which readers write about personal and family problems. Its responses offer guidance, while the choices about disclosure and family relationships remain with the people involved.