Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Does SICK OF IT ALL Have A Future Without LOU KOLLER? That’s Something You ‘Have To Just See What Happens’, Says CRAIG SETARI
SICK OF IT ALL bassist Craig Setari says the band may do something in the future following singer Lou Koller’s death, but its members have not made any firm plans. He described Koller as a brother and said it is still too soon to decide whether the group can continue without him.
Koller died in July, aged 59, after a long battle with an oesophageal tumour. Setari said Koller had encouraged the band to carry on, noting that music was central to their lives, but the group has only discussed the possibility briefly. He also reflected on the support from fans and the band’s lasting contribution to New York hardcore.
In short
- SICK OF IT ALL has no firm plans after Lou Koller’s death.
- Koller had encouraged the band to continue.
- Setari says any future activity remains uncertain.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Continuing could honour Koller’s own encouragement and keep alive the music and community that were central to the band’s life. If the remaining members feel able to perform together, doing so may offer a meaningful way to celebrate his legacy and connect with fans.
The case against
The band’s identity was deeply bound to Koller, whom Setari described as a brother, so continuing without him could feel emotionally difficult or unlike the group he helped create. Taking time, or choosing not to continue, could respect that loss and avoid making a decision before the members know what feels right.
Explained simply
Sick of It All are a New York band formed in the 1980s and associated with hardcore punk, a fast, forceful style of punk rock. Lou Koller sang in the band, while Craig Setari played bass; the two were bandmates for decades.
Koller died aged 59 after a long illness. His death leaves the other members to consider whether they want to continue performing or recording, and how they might do so without the singer who helped define the group.