Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Don’t get mad if GTA 6 sweeps The Game Awards, because it can’t beat this beloved ‘indie’ darling
GTA 6 leads this year’s Game Awards nominations with eight, prompting criticism because the game has not yet been released. The article says the nominations are chosen by a jury of more than 100 international outlets, whose members may have had advance access to the games.
The writer argues that even if GTA 6 won every category in which it is nominated, it would still collect fewer awards than Clair Obscur: Expedition 33, which has already won nine. The article contrasts the games’ reported budgets, putting GTA 6 at under $1.5 billion and Expedition 33 at $10 million, and urges readers not to root against a game they have not played.
In short
- GTA 6 has eight Game Awards nominations despite not being released.
- Expedition 33 has already won nine awards.
- The article says advance access explains how GTA 6 could be nominated.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
GTA 6’s nominations can be defended if the jury had legitimate advance access and judged the game on its merits, rather than treating its unreleased status as an automatic disqualification. Recognising anticipated craft and achievement may be consistent with awards that assess games across a year, while players can still reserve judgement until they experience it themselves.
The case against
Awards are meant to recognise games people can actually play, so nominating an unreleased title risks rewarding expectations and privileged previews over a work available for public scrutiny. Even if jurors saw it early, that can leave the process less transparent and make it harder to compare GTA 6 fairly with released games such as Clair Obscur: Expedition 33.
Explained simply
The Game Awards is an annual event that gives prizes to video games in several categories. A jury of international media outlets selects the nominees and winners, and some jurors may receive access to games before they are released.
Grand Theft Auto 6 is the next instalment in Rockstar’s long-running crime series, while Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 is a role-playing game from the smaller French studio Sandfall Interactive. Their different scale and budgets have made them part of a wider discussion about how games are made and recognised.
The awards matter because they can shape public attention and signal which games the industry values. Nominations for an unreleased game also raise questions about how jurors assess titles that most players have not yet been able to try.